What does CAC Algorithmic Recommendation Provisions (Order No. 9) say about AI in banking?

Published Dec 31, 2021 · Last reviewed Nov 20, 2026

The CAC, with MIIT, the Ministry of Public Security and SAMR, issued the Provisions on the Management of Algorithmic Recommendations in Internet Information Services as Order No. 9, dated 31 December 2021 and in force from 1 March 2022. They created China's algorithm filing system and forbid using algorithms to apply unreasonable differential pricing to consumers. Breaches of listed duties, including algorithm filing, can bring fines of 10,000 to 100,000 yuan under Article 31; a breach of the pricing ban in Article 21 is handled under other laws and rules. The official text is in Chinese.

OFFICIAL TEXT: cac.gov.cn ↗ · IN FORCE · CHINA (NFRA / PBOC / CAC)

Checked 2026-11-20 · China (NFRA / PBoC / CAC), cac.gov.cn
DocumentCAC Algorithmic Recommendation Provisions (Order No. 9) — Provisions on the Management of Algorithmic Recommendations in Internet Information Services (互联网信息服务算法推荐管理规定)
Issued byNational Financial Regulatory Administration (NFRA), People's Bank of China (PBoC) and Cyberspace Administration of China (CAC)
TypeRegulation
StatusIn force
PublishedDec 31, 2021
EffectiveMar 1, 2022
Applies toProviders of algorithmic recommendation services through internet information services in mainland China, including financial apps that personalise, rank or push content and offers. A binding departmental rule; the official text is in Chinese
Official sourcecac.gov.cn ↗
Use casesFair lending & discrimination · Customer-facing chatbots · AI governance (general)

What are the key points of CAC Algorithmic Recommendation Provisions (Order No. 9)?

  • Article 21: providers selling goods or services to consumers must not use algorithms to apply unreasonable differential treatment in prices or other trading conditions based on consumers' preferences or habits.
  • Article 24: providers with public opinion attributes or social mobilisation capacity must file their algorithm within ten working days of starting service, including an algorithm self-assessment report.
  • Filed providers must display their filing number prominently on their website or app.
  • Article 31: breaches of the listed articles, among them the filing duty in Article 24 but not the pricing rule in Article 21, bring warnings, public criticism and correction orders and, on refusal to correct or where serious, suspension of information updates and fines of 10,000 to 100,000 yuan.
  • The Generative AI Interim Measures (2023) apply this filing procedure to generative AI services with public opinion attributes.

What did CAC Algorithmic Recommendation Provisions (Order No. 9) change for banks?

The provisions introduced China's algorithm filing register and the first binding ban on algorithmic price discrimination against consumers, which reaches bank and fintech apps that personalise offers.

What does China's algorithmic recommendation rule mean for financial apps?

A financial app that personalises, ranks or pushes content or offers is an algorithmic recommendation service. Article 21 bars unreasonable differential pricing or trading conditions based on a consumer's preferences or habits, and providers with public opinion attributes must file their algorithms with the CAC.

When did the algorithmic recommendation provisions take effect?

Order No. 9 is dated 31 December 2021, was published by the CAC on 4 January 2022 and took effect on 1 March 2022. It was issued by the CAC with MIIT, the Ministry of Public Security and the State Administration for Market Regulation.

DateDocumentStatus
Mar 7, 2025CAC AI Content Labelling Measures (国信办通字〔2025〕2号) — Measures for Labelling Artificial Intelligence Generated and Synthetic Content (人工智能生成合成内容标识办法)In force
Dec 27, 2024NFRA Data Security Measures (金规〔2024〕24号) — Measures for Data Security Management of Banking and Insurance Institutions (银行保险机构数据安全管理办法)In force
Jul 10, 2023CAC Generative AI Interim Measures (Order No. 15) — Interim Measures for the Management of Generative Artificial Intelligence Services (生成式人工智能服务管理暂行办法)In force
Jan 10, 2022CBIRC Digital Transformation Opinions (银保监办发〔2022〕2号) — Guiding Opinions on the Digital Transformation of the Banking and Insurance Industries (中国银保监会办公厅关于银行业保险业数字化转型的指导意见)In force
Dec 29, 2021PBoC FinTech Development Plan 2022-2025 — FinTech Development Plan (2022-2025) (金融科技发展规划(2022-2025年))Final
Nov 19, 2026BNM AI Feedback Statement — Feedback Statement: Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the Malaysian Financial SectorFinal

Follow every document these regulators publish

when one of these regulators moves, the next morning's brief says so · six sourced stories · 7 am PT · free

plus every regulation, bank and agent page update, the morning after · leave any morning